The 7 Most Dangerous Freelancer Red Flags

Let me tell you a quick story:

A founder I was coaching thought he’d found the perfect freelancer to redesign his website.

They had all the right words—‘expert,’ ‘years of experience,’ ‘top-rated.’ Two months later, he was scrambling for cash after paying for a website that looked like it belonged in 2010. That’s when he learned a hard truth:

Not all freelancers are created equal.

Unfortunately, many founders fall into the trap of assuming that a freelancer's resume or reviews are enough.

This assumption can tank your business.

Why so many founders get burned:

• Desperation: You need the work done yesterday (and realistically, you should have hired for this WEEKS ago).
• Overpromising: Freelancers say they can do it all, and you believe them.
• No vetting: You rely too heavily on reviews and ratings, without looking closely enough at their actual work product pre-hire.
• Lack of clear scope: You think, “We’ll figure it out as we go.”

Sound familiar?

I know because I’ve made these mistakes too.

But these aren’t just mistakes; they’re pitfalls that can bleed you dry.

Here’s the seven worst you need to stay away from.

The 7 Freelancer Red Flags You Should Never Ignore

Important: If you spot even one of these red flags, hit pause. Don’t let desperation or a looming deadline force you into a bad decision.

1. The “Jack of All Trades”

You know the type: the freelancer who can design, code, write, and market your entire business into the stratosphere. Yeah, right.

I hire specialists only, because being good at everything means being great at nothing.

If you need a landing page, hire a web designer, not someone who “also” does design on the side.

2. Poor Communication

They take days to respond to simple questions or are vague about deadlines.

I look it as a marker for bigger behavior.

Pre-contract, that person wants money. They want to work together.

But If they can’t communicate clearly now, don’t expect to see anything different once you get deeper into the project.

Good freelancers are proactive communicators. They let you know if there’s a delay, ask for feedback, and confirm they’re on the right track.

3. No Portfolio or Generic Samples

I can’t emphasize this enough: a solid portfolio is non-negotiable.

Whenever I’m hiring, I hire based on past output.

If I see the kind of result I’m looking in that person’s portfolio, I can be pretty comfortable that they probably have chops to deliver what I need.

Don’t have it?

No worries - someone else does.

4. Asking for 100% Upfront Payment

Freelancers who demand full payment upfront without establishing trust or delivering milestones? Run.

On a fixed-fee project, you should be working on milestones. Pay them as they deliver, ensuring you’re not left with half-baked work and an empty wallet.

Bonus: Check the platform’s rules on refunds for incomplete work. Most refund policies are quite generous toward clients, but DYOR.

5. Lack of Professionalism

There’s no excuse for you to miss this one - and often you’ll see it before you hire.

Missed deadlines, forgotten meetings, or blaming tech issues repeatedly? Nope. I ain’t got time for that.

Some freelancers work from home in their pajamas, but that doesn’t excuse flaky behavior.

If they can’t manage their own business, how will they help yours? Set the bar high from the start.

6. Vague or Overly Complicated Contracts

If their contract reads like a novel—or worse, has no clear terms—that’s a disaster waiting to happen. You need a clear outline of deliverables, timelines, and payment terms.

It can always be handled on a single sheet of paper: who, what, when, where, how long & how much.

Simple, clear contracts protect both sides. Anything else is either A) clarification or more likely B) a recipe for frustration.

7. Too Good to Be True Rates

I get it—you don’t want to blow your budget. But if a freelancer’s rates seem too good to be true, they probably are.

Here’s the thing: Quality work costs money. The cash you save now on a cheap freelancer will come back to bite you in revisions, delays, or—worst-case—having to redo the project entirely.

So, How Do You Avoid These Red Flags?

First, don't start wringing your hands. Every founder has dealt with freelancer headaches at some point. The good news? You can avoid 90% of these problems with a better approach. Here’s how:

1. Vet thoroughly: Ask for one specific work example that represents what you’re looking for. Don’t just rely on shiny reviews.
2. Clarify everything upfront: Define the scope, deadlines, and payment structure before anyone starts working.
3. Communicate expectations: Make sure the freelancer knows how often you expect updates, and what a “finished” project looks like to you.
4. Start small: I always do a test project, figure $100-500 depending on how big of a hire it’d be. Clear goals, clear steps & timeline - and see how they do.

At the end of the day, you don’t want to waste time fixing mistakes that could’ve been avoided with a little due diligence upfront.

Now go find that A-player freelancer who will help take your business to the next level. They’re out there.

‍